So what is three time anyway?
One of the most important elements in rock music (and in most other kinds of music)
is the
rhythm. In many songs the rhythm is a straightforward pattern of
four beats. In other words it simply goes
one-two-three-four. Sometimes
it's close to an even simpler one-two pattern. This is the most common rhythm,
and in many musical genres you rarely hear anything else. In reggae interestingly
the pattern has four beats as well, but with emphasis on the third one:
one-two-
three-four.
It's somehow much harder to write a good song with a three beat rhythm.
Songs that follow this pattern are said to be in three time. One of the most
well known examples is Three times a lady (note the reference in the title)
by Lionel Ritchie. The rhythm follows an obvious
one-two-three-one-two-three-one-two-three pattern.
This example is also a good example of how songs in three time generally tend to
be a bit slower, a bit less dynamic than those in regular four time. By the way,
in some songs not every emphasis on the first beat is equally strong. Instead they
alternate between a stronger and weaker one. You could describe this by a
one-two-three-one-two-three pattern. Musicians usually call this
a six eighths pattern.
So why is it so special?
Since songs in four time are appealing more quickly, are usually more dynamic,
are easier to dance to and are probably easier to write as well it's no surprise
that they form a huge majority. Over the years several rock bands
have tried to write creative and alternative efforts, and it's there we can find
several examples of three time. Still, even in rock music alternative rhythms are
not too common, so it is amazing to find that the Cocteau Twins often wrote a large
part of their material in three time - on
Treasure more
than half the songs are in three time, something very rare indeed.
So do you have any examples of bands and songs?
In the table at the bottom of this page you'll find a number of examples, mostly
in alternative/indie rock genre. Where many bands just produced the odd song in
three time the Cocteau Twins wrote an amazing
forty-one songs in this rhythm.
As you can see
Dead Can Dance are another band who wrote many creative
rhythms. From several other bands or artists you'll find a number of entries,
but in many cases it's just one or two. Three time songs are pretty rare!
(Note: this list is definitely not even close to complete, so if you feel
you have some useful additions to this list why don't you mail them to
).
Some of those songs are not so slow though...
When you listen to a song like
Beatrix it's clear
this is a typical example of a slower song. Similarly
Grail Overfloweth,
Five Ten Fiftyfold and
Road, River And Rail are not too quick.
But songs in three time can have much quicker rhythms by making the three beats
so quick that the listener actually experiences the three beats as one 'superbeat'.
This is a technique the Twins used often. In
The Tinderbox (Of A Heart) the three time pattern is still obvious, but already
too quick to easily move along with. In
Ivo the three
time is even quicker. The quickest three time they ever did is probably in
Athol-Brose where three beats are fired so rapidly
it's hard not to experience them as a single beat.
But what about other rhythms? Or perhaps you can mix them!
Well, yes, of course, you could use still other rhythms. You could use a five beat
rhythm (usually called 5/8) -
Take Five by
Dave Brubeck is probably
the most famous example. Songs with such rhythms are even rarer though. Mixing two
different rhythms into a single song is another extremely rare technique. They do
exist though, and you'll find the few examples of such unusual rhythms that I am
aware of described in the second table below.
|
Some bands and (some of) their songs in three time |
| Cocteau Twins |
| On Garlands : |
Blind Dumb Deaf; Shallow Then Halo;
Grail Overfloweth |
| On BBC Sessions : |
(apart from songs appearing elsewhere as well) Dear Heart
| | On Lullabies : |
Alas Dies Laughing; It's All But An Ark Lark |
| On Peppermint Pig : |
Laugh Lines; Hazel |
| On Head Over Heels : |
Five Ten Fiftyfold; Sugar Hiccup;Glass Candle Grenades;
The Tinderbox (Of A Heart); Musette And Drums |
| On Sunburst And Snowblind : |
Hitherto |
| On The Spangle Maker : |
Pearly-Dewdrops' Drops; Pepper-Tree |
| On Treasure : |
Ivo; Beatrix; Persephone; Pandora; Amelia; Cicely |
| On Aikea-Guinea : |
Rococo |
| On Tiny Dynamine : |
Sultitan Itan |
| On Echoes In A Shallow Bay : |
Melonella; Pale Clouded White |
| On Victorialand : |
Throughout The Dark Months Of April And May; Little Spacey |
| On The Moon And The Melodies : |
Sea, Swallow Me; Eyes Are Mosaics;
She Will Destroy You; Ooze Out And Away, Onehow |
| On Love's Easy Tears : |
Those Eyes, That Mouth |
| On Blue Bell Knoll : |
Athol-Brose |
| On Heaven Or Las Vegas : |
Fotzepolitic; Road, River And Rail |
| On Four-Calendar Café : |
Theft, And Wandering Around Lost; My Truth |
| On Milk & Kisses : |
Ups |
| On Violaine : |
Circling Girl |
| On Volume 17 : |
Touch Upon Touch |
|
| Dead Can Dance |
| On Dead Can Dance : |
Frontier; Ocean; Wild In The Woods;
Carnival Of Light; Flowers Of The Sea |
On Throughout The Realm Of A Dying Sun : |
Cantara; Summoning Of The Muse |
| On The Serpents Egg : |
The Writing On My Father's Hand; Ullyses |
| On Aion : |
Fortune Presents Gifts Not According To the Book; Black Sun; Radharc |
| On Into The Labyrinth : |
Towards The Within |
| On Toward The Within : |
I Can See Now |
| On Spiritchaser : |
Song Of The Stars; Indus; Song Of The Nile |
|
| The Smiths |
That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore; Meat Is murder; I Know It's Over;
Never Had No One Ever; Stretch Out And Wait |
| Siouxsie & The Banshees |
The Staircase (Mystery); Playground Twist; Red Light; Obsession; Circle; Melt!;
The Last Beat Of My Heart |
| The Creatures |
Pluto Drive; I Was Me |
| Genesis |
The Return Of The Giant Hogweed; Entangled; Like It Or Not |
| Garbage |
Can't Cry These Tears; Drive You Home |
| Lush |
De-Luxe; Thoughtforms; Covert; Laura; Monochrome; White Wood; Shut Up |
| Cranes |
Watersong; Thursday; Leaves Of Summer; Starblood; Sixth Of May; Wish;
Beautiful Sadness; Adrift; And Ever; Golden; Fourteen |
| Echo and the Bunnymen |
Nocturnal Me;The Yo-Yo Man |
| Kate Bush |
Army Dreamers; Suspended In Gaffa; Night Of The Swallow |
| This Ascension |
Chameleon Room; Light And Shade; Angel Light; Placid;
Forever Shaken |
| Mira |
Stainless; Pieces; Passerby; Nearest Exit |
| Big Country |
Close Action |
| Toyah |
I Want To Be Free |
| Catatonia |
Strange Glue |
| Echobelly |
Taste Of You; Cold Feet Warm Heart; Natural Animal;
Something Hot In A Cold Country; Worms And Angels; Atom;
Bulldog Baby |
| Journey |
Lovin' Touchin' Squeezin'; I'm Cryin'; Stay Awhile;
Open Arms; Happy To Give |
| Kansas |
Portrait (He Knew) |
| The Beatles |
She's Leaving Home |
| Queen |
Somebody To Love; We Are The Champions |
| Fleetwood Mac |
Albatross |
| Pink Floyd |
Astronomy Domine; One Of These Days |
| U2 |
Trip Through Your Wires |
| Moody Blues |
Nights In White Satin |
| Led Zeppelin |
Dazed And Confused |
| Within Temptation |
Mother Earth; The Promise;Never-ending Story;
Overcome; The Howling; All I Need |
|
Some even more unusual rhythms and combinations |
| Cranes |
You won't find many rock songs in 5/8, but Cha Cha Escueta (on
The EP Collection) and Pale Blue Sky (on Loved)
are two rare examples. |
| The Beatles |
Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds is probably one of their most famous songs.
But did you ever notice the verse is in three time, but the chorus isn't? |
| Led Zeppelin |
The lengthy song Kashmir has a very complicated rhythm: it alternates
many times between three time and four time. |
| The Stranglers |
Ever wondered why Golden Brown sounds so peculiar? The verse has a
highly uncommon 3-3-3-4 rhythm. |
| This Ascension |
Both the first and last parts of Sandman, from their
Walk Softly, A Dream Lies Here album are in three time,
but the middle part starts out in 3-3-3-1 (10/16) before switching to 5/8. |
| Mira |
On the album Apart the band experiment a lot with rhythm changes. Green
changes halfway from three time to four time before finishing off in three time again.
In Plastique the band confusingly alternate between what appears to be three time
but really is a 3-3-3-3-3-1 pattern and a regular four time, before closing off in
proper three time. While Tick Tock is mostly in three time halfway it features a
four time passage. |
| Siouxsie & the Banshees |
On their debut album The Scream there is Overground. The chorus
has a standard rhythm, but the verse is in a 3-3-4 (or 10/16) rhythm. |
| Genesis |
The epic Supper's Ready on Foxtrot contains a lengthy episode where
the rhythm famously has a nine beat pattern. |
| Garbage |
On Beautifulgarbage you'll find Silence Is Golden. The first part of
that song is in three time, but the concluding part is in four time. |
| Dead Can Dance |
One of their most mystifying tracks on The Serpent's Egg is Echolalia.
Most of this song has a dazzling 13/16 rhythm. |
|
|